Skip to content

ThanksgivingOrders are open for Wednesday, November 25, pickup or delivery, until things sell out. Order sourdough by Monday night to guarantee a loaf.

Billy Bread
The Journal

Learning Panettone: Three Days, Two Failures and One Very Tall Bread

✦ ✦ ✦

Three days, two failed attempts, one very tall bread

I’ve been baking sourdough since 2012. I thought I knew what a hard bread was. Then this fall I decided to learn panettone, and it put me right back at the beginning.

Billy holding his first finished panettone in the Billy Bread kitchen in Newbury Park

What is panettone?

Panettone is the tall, domed Christmas bread from Milan. It’s rich with butter, egg yolks, sugar and honey, full of raisins and candied orange, and scented with vanilla, orange and lemon. A real one is light and tears apart in long, silky strands. It is nothing like the dry one in the decorative box at the grocery store.

The panettone I’m chasing is From Roy’s. Roy’s panettone is the one that made a lot of Americans take this bread seriously: tall, shreddy and so soft it pulls apart in feathers. I’m working from a version of his classic recipe, and I’m not there yet. But I’m getting closer.

What makes it so hard is that there’s no commercial yeast. The whole thing rises on a natural starter, the same idea as my sourdough, while carrying more butter, sugar and yolks than any dough has a right to lift.

A different starter, just for panettone

My regular starter is wet and tangy. That’s great for sourdough and wrong for panettone, where you want it sweet and mild, not sour. So I took some of my regular starter and raised it into a separate one just for panettone, called a lievito madre. It’s stiff, more like a ball of dough than a batter, and it lives on strong Italian panettone flour.

It’s also needy. Before a bake it gets fed three times a day and kept warm, around 84 to 86°F. I don’t start until it triples in about three and a half to four hours, three feeds in a row. If it’s slow, I wait.

How long does panettone take?

About three days, start to finish.

  • Getting the starter ready: a day or two of warm feeds until it’s strong and predictable.
  • Day 1: the starter gets a soak in sugar water to sweeten it up, three more feeds, and then the first dough in the evening. It rises overnight until it triples.
  • Day 2: the second dough. In go the yolks, butter, sugar, honey, vanilla, citrus and fruit, a little at a time on the lowest speeds. Then it proofs in tall paper molds until it’s about 3/4 inch from the rim.
  • The bake: an almond glaze and pearl sugar on top, then about 55 minutes at 340°F, until the center reads 199°F.
  • The hang: straight out of the oven, I skewer it and hang it upside down for 10 to 12 hours.

Why does panettone hang upside down?

Because it’s so rich and so airy that, hot out of the oven, it can’t hold up its own weight. Set it down right side up and the dome sinks into itself. Hanging it upside down lets the crumb set while gravity pulls it tall instead of flat. It’s also the most ridiculous-looking thing I’ve ever done in my kitchen.

The first two didn’t make it

My first attempt in October fell apart at the second dough. I added all the sugar and honey at once, and the dough turned into paste. I baked the leftover dough in a loaf pan just to see, and it actually tasted good. That told me the starter was fine and my mixing was the problem. Now the sugar goes in slowly, in halves.

The second attempt never got mixed at all. I started it the same week as a Billy Bread bake day, and the bread orders won. Lesson learned: panettone and Fresh Bread Friday don’t share a week.

The third one

Panettone cut in half showing an open crumb with tall holes and candied orange

Here it is. A tall dome that didn’t sink, fruit spread evenly all the way through, and a crumb with those long, vertical holes I’ve been chasing. I was pretty proud of it.

It’s not perfect, and I’ll tell you why. On the second day I mixed up my notes and added the first day’s water to the second dough, then fixed it with extra flour by eye. You can see a few tighter, more brioche-like patches in the crumb, and that’s my guess for why. The almond glaze cracked into little islands instead of covering the top. And I left the loaves out unbagged, so by day two it was a little dry. Still good, though. The small loaf-pan piece disappeared fast.

The top of a panettone with almond glaze and pearl sugar

What’s next

More bakes. I want it consistent, the same tall, open, shreddy loaf every time, before I’d ever hand one to you. Next time, the right amount of water, a thicker glaze spread to the edges, and every loaf bagged the moment it comes off the hang.

I’m not selling panettone yet, but I’m hoping to have them ready for Christmas. If you’d like to hear first when they’re available, join the bread list. And in the meantime, the sourdough is in the shop every week, no three-day wait required.