
Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake
Have you ever had Gooey Butter Cake? Maybe the butter cake at Maestro’s? It’s like that, but better, because of the extra gooey. A dense, buttery cake with a soft, custardy pumpkin top and warm fall spices. Extremely rich. Two sizes: the Small (4″ x 5″) for $13, best shared, but nobody’s judging. The Large (8″ x 8″) for $30, the big one for the Thanksgiving dessert table. Keeps beautifully in the fridge until Thanksgiving; let it come to room temperature before serving for maximum gooey glory. Thanksgiving pickup only, 11/25, the day before Thanksgiving.
- When
- Baked fresh Wednesday in small batches. Order a couple of days ahead to be safe.
- Pickup
- Always free at the Newbury Park kitchen. Billy texts you when it’s ready.
- Delivery
- $3 in Newbury Park, $5 to Thousand Oaks, Westlake Village, and Lake Sherwood. Areas we serve
What people say about the Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake
“As always everthing was wonderful,.looking forward to placing my order for Christmas”
Karen M. · December 8, 2025
“This was so good that I only got one bite. My guests devoured the rest before I had a chance to serve myself an actual piece. Will definitely order again!”
Eric B. · December 12, 2024



