Skip to content

ThanksgivingOrders are open for Wednesday, November 25, pickup or delivery, until things sell out. Order sourdough by Monday night to guarantee a loaf.

Billy Bread
The Shop / Sweets
Baked Wednesday · Newbury Park
Large 8x8 and small 4x5 pumpkin gooey butter cakes in foil pans

Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake

from $13
5.0 · 3 reviews

Have you ever had Gooey Butter Cake? Maybe the butter cake at Maestro’s? It’s like that, but better, because of the extra gooey. A dense, buttery cake with a soft, custardy pumpkin top and warm fall spices. Extremely rich. Two sizes: the Small (4″ x 5″) for $13, best shared, but nobody’s judging. The Large (8″ x 8″) for $30, the big one for the Thanksgiving dessert table. Keeps beautifully in the fridge until Thanksgiving; let it come to room temperature before serving for maximum gooey glory. Thanksgiving pickup only, 11/25, the day before Thanksgiving.

When
Baked fresh Wednesday in small batches. Order a couple of days ahead to be safe.
Pickup
Always free at the Newbury Park kitchen. Billy texts you when it’s ready.
Delivery
$3 in Newbury Park, $5 to Thousand Oaks, Westlake Village, and Lake Sherwood. Areas we serve

What people say about the Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake

  • “As always everthing was wonderful,.looking forward to placing my order for Christmas”

    Karen M. · December 8, 2025

  • “This was so good that I only got one bite. My guests devoured the rest before I had a chance to serve myself an actual piece. Will definitely order again!”

    Eric B. · December 12, 2024